source: fedd/federation/emulab_access.py @ f24fc8d

#!/usr/local/bin/python

import os,sys
import stat # for chmod constants
import re
import random
import string
import copy
import pickle
import logging
import subprocess
import traceback
import socket

from threading import *
from M2Crypto.SSL import SSLError

from access import access_base

from util import *
from deter import fedid, generate_fedid
from authorizer import authorizer, abac_authorizer
from service_error import service_error
from remote_service import xmlrpc_handler, soap_handler, service_caller
from proof import proof as access_proof

import httplib
import tempfile
from urlparse import urlparse

from deter import topdl
import list_log
import emulab_segment


# Make log messages disappear if noone configures a fedd logger
class nullHandler(logging.Handler):
    def emit(self, record): pass

fl = logging.getLogger("fedd.access")
fl.addHandler(nullHandler())

class access(access_base):
    """
    The implementation of access control based on mapping users to projects.

    Users can be mapped to existing projects or have projects created
    dynamically.  This implements both direct requests and proxies.
    """

    max_name_len = 19

    def __init__(self, config=None, auth=None):
        """
        Initializer.  Pulls parameters out of the ConfigParser's access section.
        """

        access_base.__init__(self, config, auth)

        self.max_name_len = access.max_name_len

        self.allow_proxy = config.getboolean("access", "allow_proxy")

        self.domain = config.get("access", "domain")
        self.userconfdir = config.get("access","userconfdir")
        self.userconfcmd = config.get("access","userconfcmd")
        self.userconfurl = config.get("access","userconfurl")
        self.federation_software = config.get("access", "federation_software")
        self.portal_software = config.get("access", "portal_software")
        self.local_seer_software = config.get("access", "local_seer_software")
        self.local_seer_image = config.get("access", "local_seer_image")
        self.local_seer_start = config.get("access", "local_seer_start")
        self.seer_master_start = config.get("access", "seer_master_start")
        self.ssh_privkey_file = config.get("access","ssh_privkey_file")
        self.ssh_pubkey_file = config.get("access","ssh_pubkey_file")
        self.ssh_port = config.get("access","ssh_port") or "22"
        self.boss = config.get("access", "boss")
        self.ops = config.get("access", "ops")
        self.xmlrpc_cert = config.get("access", "xmlrpc_cert")
        self.xmlrpc_certpw = config.get("access", "xmlrpc_certpw")

        self.dragon_endpoint = config.get("access", "dragon")
        self.dragon_vlans = config.get("access", "dragon_vlans")
        self.deter_internal = config.get("access", "deter_internal")

        self.tunnel_config = config.getboolean("access", "tunnel_config")
        self.portal_command = config.get("access", "portal_command")
        self.portal_image = config.get("access", "portal_image")
        self.portal_type = config.get("access", "portal_type") or "pc"
        self.portal_startcommand = config.get("access", "portal_startcommand")
        self.node_startcommand = config.get("access", "node_startcommand")
        self.nat_portal = config.get("access", "nat_portal")

        self.uri = 'https://%s:%d' % (socket.getfqdn(), 
                self.get_port(config.get("globals", "services", "23235")))

        self.federation_software = self.software_list(self.federation_software)
        self.portal_software = self.software_list(self.portal_software)
        self.local_seer_software = self.software_list(self.local_seer_software)

        self.access_type = self.access_type.lower()
        self.start_segment = emulab_segment.start_segment
        self.stop_segment = emulab_segment.stop_segment
        self.info_segment = emulab_segment.info_segment
        self.operation_segment = emulab_segment.operation_segment

        self.restricted = [ ]
        tb = config.get('access', 'testbed')
        if tb: self.testbed = [ t.strip() for t in tb.split(',') ]
        else: self.testbed = [ ]

        # authorization information
        self.auth_type = config.get('access', 'auth_type') \
                or 'abac'
        self.auth_dir = config.get('access', 'auth_dir')
        accessdb = config.get("access", "accessdb")
        # initialize the authorization system
        if self.auth_type == 'abac':
            self.auth = abac_authorizer(load=self.auth_dir)
            self.access = [ ]
            if accessdb:
                self.read_access(accessdb, self.access_tuple)
        else:
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, 
                    "Unknown auth_type: %s" % self.auth_type)

        # read_state in the base_class
        self.state_lock.acquire()
        if 'allocation' not in self.state: self.state['allocation']= { }
        self.allocation = self.state['allocation']
        self.state_lock.release()
        self.exports = {
                'SMB': self.export_SMB,
                'seer': self.export_seer,
                'tmcd': self.export_tmcd,
                'userconfig': self.export_userconfig,
                'project_export': self.export_project_export,
                'local_seer_control': self.export_local_seer,
                'seer_master': self.export_seer_master,
                'hide_hosts': self.export_hide_hosts,
                }

        if not self.local_seer_image or not self.local_seer_software or \
                not self.local_seer_start:
            if 'local_seer_control' in self.exports:
                del self.exports['local_seer_control']

        if not self.local_seer_image or not self.local_seer_software or \
                not self.seer_master_start:
            if 'seer_master' in self.exports:
                del self.exports['seer_master']


        self.soap_services = {\
            'RequestAccess': soap_handler("RequestAccess", self.RequestAccess),
            'ReleaseAccess': soap_handler("ReleaseAccess", self.ReleaseAccess),
            'StartSegment': soap_handler("StartSegment", self.StartSegment),
            'TerminateSegment': soap_handler("TerminateSegment",
                self.TerminateSegment),
            'InfoSegment': soap_handler("InfoSegment", self.InfoSegment),
            'OperationSegment': soap_handler("OperationSegment",
                self.OperationSegment),
            }
        self.xmlrpc_services =  {\
            'RequestAccess': xmlrpc_handler('RequestAccess',
                self.RequestAccess),
            'ReleaseAccess': xmlrpc_handler('ReleaseAccess',
                self.ReleaseAccess),
            'StartSegment': xmlrpc_handler("StartSegment", self.StartSegment),
            'TerminateSegment': xmlrpc_handler('TerminateSegment',
                self.TerminateSegment),
            'InfoSegment': xmlrpc_handler("InfoSegment", self.InfoSegment),
            'OperationSegment': xmlrpc_handler("OperationSegment",
                self.OperationSegment),
            }

        self.call_SetValue = service_caller('SetValue', log=self.log)
        self.call_GetValue = service_caller('GetValue', log=self.log)

    @staticmethod
    def get_port(ps):
        '''
        Take a fedd service string and return the first port.  Used in 
        creating the testbed uri identifier.
        '''
        p = ps.split(',')
        smallport = p[0].split(':')
        try:
            rv = int(smallport[0])
        except ValueError:
            rv = 23235
        return rv

    @staticmethod
    def access_tuple(str):
        """
        Convert a string of the form (id, id, id) into an access_project.  This
        is called by read_access to convert to local attributes.  It returns a
        tuple of the form (project, user, certificate_file).
        """

        str = str.strip()
        if str.startswith('(') and str.endswith(')') and str.count(',') == 2:
            # The slice takes the parens off the string.
            proj, user, cert = str[1:-1].split(',')
            return (proj.strip(), user.strip(), cert.strip())
        else:
            raise self.parse_error(
                    'Bad mapping (unbalanced parens or more than 2 commas)')

    # RequestAccess support routines

    def save_project_state(self, aid, pname, uname, certf, owners):
        """
        Save the project, user, and owners associated with this allocation.
        This creates the allocation entry.
        """
        self.state_lock.acquire()
        self.allocation[aid] = { }
        self.allocation[aid]['project'] = pname
        self.allocation[aid]['user'] = uname
        self.allocation[aid]['cert'] = certf
        self.allocation[aid]['owners'] = owners
        self.write_state()
        self.state_lock.release()
        return (pname, uname)

    # End of RequestAccess support routines

    def RequestAccess(self, req, fid):
        """
        Handle the access request.  Proxy if not for us.

        Parse out the fields and make the allocations or rejections if for us,
        otherwise, assuming we're willing to proxy, proxy the request out.
        """

        def gateway_hardware(h):
            if h == 'GWTYPE': return self.portal_type or 'GWTYPE'
            else: return h

        def get_export_project(svcs):
            """
            if the service requests includes one to export a project, return
            that project.
            """
            rv = None
            for s in svcs:
                if s.get('name', '') == 'project_export' and \
                        s.get('visibility', '') == 'export':
                    if not rv: 
                        for a in s.get('fedAttr', []):
                            if a.get('attribute', '') == 'project' \
                                    and 'value' in a:
                                rv = a['value']
                    else:
                        raise service_error(service_error, access, 
                                'Requesting multiple project exports is ' + \
                                        'not supported');
            return rv

        self.log.info("RequestAccess called by %s" % fid)
        # The dance to get into the request body
        if req.has_key('RequestAccessRequestBody'):
            req = req['RequestAccessRequestBody']
        else:
            raise service_error(service_error.req, "No request!?")

        # if this includes a project export request, construct a filter such
        # that only the ABAC attributes mapped to that project are checked for
        # access.
        if 'service' in req:
            ep = get_export_project(req['service'])
            if ep: pf = lambda(a): a.value[0] == ep
            else: pf = None
        else:
            ep = None
            pf = None

        if self.auth.import_credentials(
                data_list=req.get('abac_credential', [])):
            self.auth.save()
        else:
            self.log.debug('failed to import incoming credentials')

        if self.auth_type == 'abac':
            found, owners, proof = self.lookup_access(req, fid, filter=pf)
        else:
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, 
                    'Unknown auth_type: %s' % self.auth_type)
        ap = None

        # keep track of what's been added
        allocID, alloc_cert = generate_fedid(subj="alloc", log=self.log)
        aid = unicode(allocID)

        pname, uname = self.save_project_state(aid, found[0], found[1], 
                found[2], owners)

        services, svc_state = self.export_services(req.get('service',[]),
                pname, uname)
        self.state_lock.acquire()
        # Store services state in global state
        for k, v in svc_state.items():
            self.allocation[aid][k] = v
        self.append_allocation_authorization(aid, 
                set([(o, allocID) for o in owners]), state_attr='allocation')
        self.write_state()
        self.state_lock.release()
        try:
            f = open("%s/%s.pem" % (self.certdir, aid), "w")
            print >>f, alloc_cert
            f.close()
        except EnvironmentError, e:
            self.log.info("RequestAccess failed for by %s: internal error" \
                    % fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, 
                    "Can't open %s/%s : %s" % (self.certdir, aid, e))
        self.log.debug('RequestAccess Returning allocation ID: %s' % allocID)
        resp = self.build_access_response({ 'fedid': allocID } ,
                pname, services, proof)
        return resp

    def ReleaseAccess(self, req, fid):
        self.log.info("ReleaseAccess called by %s" % fid)
        # The dance to get into the request body
        if req.has_key('ReleaseAccessRequestBody'):
            req = req['ReleaseAccessRequestBody']
        else:
            raise service_error(service_error.req, "No request!?")

        try:
            if req['allocID'].has_key('localname'):
                auth_attr = aid = req['allocID']['localname']
            elif req['allocID'].has_key('fedid'):
                aid = unicode(req['allocID']['fedid'])
                auth_attr = req['allocID']['fedid']
            else:
                raise service_error(service_error.req,
                        "Only localnames and fedids are understood")
        except KeyError:
            raise service_error(service_error.req, "Badly formed request")

        self.log.debug("[access] deallocation requested for %s by %s" % \
                (aid, fid))
        access_ok, proof = self.auth.check_attribute(fid, auth_attr, 
                with_proof=True)
        if not access_ok:
            self.log.debug("[access] deallocation denied for %s", aid)
            raise service_error(service_error.access, "Access Denied")

        self.state_lock.acquire()
        if aid in self.allocation:
            self.log.debug("Found allocation for %s" %aid)
            self.clear_allocation_authorization(aid, state_attr='allocation')
            del self.allocation[aid]
            self.write_state()
            self.state_lock.release()
            # Remove the access cert
            cf = "%s/%s.pem" % (self.certdir, aid)
            self.log.debug("Removing %s" % cf)
            os.remove(cf)
            self.log.info("ReleaseAccess succeeded for %s" % fid)
            return { 'allocID': req['allocID'], 'proof': proof.to_dict() } 
        else:
            self.state_lock.release()
            raise service_error(service_error.req, "No such allocation")

    # These are subroutines for StartSegment
    def generate_ns2(self, topo, expfn, softdir, connInfo):
        """
        Convert topo into an ns2 file, decorated with appropriate commands for
        the particular testbed setup.  Convert all requests for software, etc
        to point at the staged copies on this testbed and add the federation
        startcommands.
        """
        class dragon_commands:
            """
            Functor to spit out approrpiate dragon commands for nodes listed in
            the connectivity description.  The constructor makes a dict mapping
            dragon nodes to their parameters and the __call__ checks each
            element in turn for membership.
            """
            def __init__(self, map):
                self.node_info = map

            def __call__(self, e):
                s = ""
                if isinstance(e, topdl.Computer):
                    if self.node_info.has_key(e.name):
                        info = self.node_info[e.name]
                        for ifname, vlan, type in info:
                            for i in e.interface:
                                if i.name == ifname:
                                    addr = i.get_attribute('ip4_address')
                                    subs = i.substrate[0]
                                    break
                            else:
                                raise service_error(service_error.internal,
                                        "No interface %s on element %s" % \
                                                (ifname, e.name))
                            # XXX: do netmask right
                            if type =='link':
                                s = ("tb-allow-external ${%s} " + \
                                        "dragonportal ip %s vlan %s " + \
                                        "netmask 255.255.255.0\n") % \
                                        (topdl.to_tcl_name(e.name), addr, vlan)
                            elif type =='lan':
                                s = ("tb-allow-external ${%s} " + \
                                        "dragonportal " + \
                                        "ip %s vlan %s usurp %s\n") % \
                                        (topdl.to_tcl_name(e.name), addr, 
                                                vlan, subs)
                            else:
                                raise service_error(service_error_internal,
                                        "Unknown DRAGON type %s" % type)
                return s

        class not_dragon:
            """
            Return true if a node is in the given map of dragon nodes.
            """
            def __init__(self, map):
                self.nodes = set(map.keys())

            def __call__(self, e):
                return e.name not in self.nodes

        def have_portals(top):
            '''
            Return true if the topology has a portal node
            '''
            # The else is on the for
            for e in top.elements:
                if isinstance(e, topdl.Computer) and e.get_attribute('portal'):
                    return True
            else:
                return False


        # Main line of generate_ns2
        t = topo.clone()

        # Create the map of nodes that need direct connections (dragon
        # connections) from the connInfo
        dragon_map = { }
        for i in [ i for i in connInfo if i['type'] == 'transit']:
            for a in i.get('fedAttr', []):
                if a['attribute'] == 'vlan_id':
                    vlan = a['value']
                    break
            else:
                raise service_error(service_error.internal, "No vlan tag")
            members = i.get('member', [])
            if len(members) > 1: type = 'lan'
            else: type = 'link'

            try:
                for m in members:
                    if m['element'] in dragon_map:
                        dragon_map[m['element']].append(( m['interface'], 
                            vlan, type))
                    else:
                        dragon_map[m['element']] = [( m['interface'], 
                            vlan, type),]
            except KeyError:
                raise service_error(service_error.req,
                        "Missing connectivity info")

        def output_fixed_filter(e):
            if not isinstance(e, topdl.Computer): return ""
            fn = e.get_attribute('fixed')
            if fn is None:
                return ""
            else:
                return 'tb-fix-node ${%s} %s' % (topdl.to_tcl_name(e.name), fn)

        # Weed out the things we aren't going to instantiate: Segments, portal
        # substrates, and portal interfaces.  (The copy in the for loop allows
        # us to delete from e.elements in side the for loop).  While we're
        # touching all the elements, we also adjust paths from the original
        # testbed to local testbed paths and put the federation commands into
        # the start commands
        local = len(dragon_map) == 0 and not have_portals(t)
        if local: routing = 'Static'
        else: routing = 'Manual'

        if local:
            self.log.debug("Local experiment.")
        for e in [e for e in t.elements]:
            if isinstance(e, topdl.Segment):
                t.elements.remove(e)
            if isinstance(e, topdl.Computer):
                self.add_kit(e, self.federation_software)
                if e.get_attribute('portal') and self.portal_startcommand:
                    # Add local portal support software
                    self.add_kit(e, self.portal_software)
                    # Portals never have a user-specified start command
                    e.set_attribute('startup', self.portal_startcommand)
                elif not local and self.node_startcommand:
                    if e.get_attribute('startup'):
                        e.set_attribute('startup', "%s \\$USER '%s'" % \
                                (self.node_startcommand, 
                                    e.get_attribute('startup')))
                    else:
                        e.set_attribute('startup', self.node_startcommand)

                dinf = [i[0] for i in dragon_map.get(e.name, []) ]
                # Remove portal interfaces that do not connect to DRAGON
                e.interface = [i for i in e.interface \
                        if not i.get_attribute('portal') or i.name in dinf ]
            # Fix software paths
            for s in getattr(e, 'software', []):
                s.location = re.sub("^.*/", softdir, s.location)

        t.substrates = [ s.clone() for s in t.substrates ]
        t.incorporate_elements()

        # Customize the ns2 output for local portal commands and images
        filters = [output_fixed_filter]

        if self.dragon_endpoint:
            add_filter = not_dragon(dragon_map)
            filters.append(dragon_commands(dragon_map))
        else:
            add_filter = None

        if self.portal_command:
            filters.append(topdl.generate_portal_command_filter(
                self.portal_command, add_filter=add_filter))

        if self.portal_image:
            filters.append(topdl.generate_portal_image_filter(
                self.portal_image))

        if self.portal_type:
            filters.append(topdl.generate_portal_hardware_filter(
                self.portal_type))

        # Convert to ns and write it out
        expfile = topdl.topology_to_ns2(t, filters, routing=routing)
        try:
            f = open(expfn, "w")
            print >>f, expfile
            f.close()
        except EnvironmentError:
            raise service_error(service_error.internal,
                    "Cannot write experiment file %s: %s" % (expfn,e))

    def export_store_info(self, cf, proj, ename, connInfo):
        """
        For the export requests in the connection info, install the peer names
        at the experiment controller via SetValue calls.
        """

        for c in connInfo:
            for p in [ p for p in c.get('parameter', []) \
                    if p.get('type', '') == 'output']:

                if p.get('name', '') == 'peer':
                    k = p.get('key', None)
                    surl = p.get('store', None)
                    if surl :
                        if self.nat_portal:
                            value = self.nat_portal
                        elif k and k.index('/') != -1:
                            value = "%s.%s.%s%s" % \
                                (k[k.index('/')+1:], ename, proj, self.domain)
                        else: 
                            self.log.error("Bad export request: %s" % p)
                            continue
                        self.log.debug("Setting %s to %s on %s" % \
                                (k, value, surl))
                        req = { 'name': k, 'value': value }
                        self.call_SetValue(surl, req, cf)
                    else:
                        self.log.error("Bad export request: %s" % p)
                elif p.get('name', '') == 'ssh_port':
                    k = p.get('key', None)
                    surl = p.get('store', None)
                    if surl and k:
                        req = { 'name': k, 'value': self.ssh_port }
                        self.log.debug("Setting %s to %s on %s" % \
                                (k, self.ssh_port, surl))
                        self.call_SetValue(surl, req, cf)
                    else:
                        self.log.error("Bad export request: %s" % p)
                else:
                    self.log.error("Unknown export parameter: %s" % \
                            p.get('name'))
                    continue

    def add_seer_node(self, topo, name, startup):
        """
        Add a seer node to the given topology, with the startup command passed
        in.  Used by configure seer_services.
        """
        c_node = topdl.Computer(
                name=name, 
                os= topdl.OperatingSystem(
                    attribute=[
                    { 'attribute': 'osid', 
                        'value': self.local_seer_image },
                    ]),
                attribute=[
                    { 'attribute': 'startup', 'value': startup },
                    ]
                )
        self.add_kit(c_node, self.local_seer_software)
        topo.elements.append(c_node)

    def configure_seer_services(self, services, topo, softdir):
        """
        Make changes to the topology required for the seer requests being made.
        Specifically, add any control or master nodes required and set up the
        start commands on the nodes to interconnect them.
        """
        local_seer = False      # True if we need to add a control node
        collect_seer = False    # True if there is a seer-master node
        seer_master= False      # True if we need to add the seer-master
        for s in services:
            s_name = s.get('name', '')
            s_vis = s.get('visibility','')

            if s_name  == 'local_seer_control' and s_vis == 'export':
                local_seer = True
            elif s_name == 'seer_master':
                if s_vis == 'import':
                    collect_seer = True
                elif s_vis == 'export':
                    seer_master = True
        
        # We've got the whole picture now, so add nodes if needed and configure
        # them to interconnect properly.
        if local_seer or seer_master:
            # Copy local seer control node software to the tempdir
            for l, f in self.local_seer_software:
                base = os.path.basename(f)
                copy_file(f, "%s/%s" % (softdir, base))
        # If we're collecting seers somewhere the controllers need to talk to
        # the master.  In testbeds that export the service, that will be a
        # local node that we'll add below.  Elsewhere it will be the control
        # portal that will port forward to the exporting master.
        if local_seer:
            if collect_seer:
                startup = "%s -C %s" % (self.local_seer_start, "seer-master")
            else:
                startup = self.local_seer_start
            self.add_seer_node(topo, 'control', startup)
        # If this is the seer master, add that node, too.
        if seer_master:
            self.add_seer_node(topo, 'seer-master', 
                    "%s -R -n -R seer-master -R -A -R sink" % \
                            self.seer_master_start)

    def retrieve_software(self, topo, certfile, softdir):
        """
        Collect the software that nodes in the topology need loaded and stage
        it locally.  This implies retrieving it from the experiment_controller
        and placing it into softdir.  Certfile is used to prove that this node
        has access to that data (it's the allocation/segment fedid).  Finally
        local portal and federation software is also copied to the same staging
        directory for simplicity - all software needed for experiment creation
        is in softdir.
        """
        sw = set()
        for e in topo.elements:
            for s in getattr(e, 'software', []):
                sw.add(s.location)
        for s in sw:
            self.log.debug("Retrieving %s" % s)
            try:
                get_url(s, certfile, softdir, log=self.log)
            except:
                t, v, st = sys.exc_info()
                raise service_error(service_error.internal,
                        "Error retrieving %s: %s" % (s, v))

        # Copy local federation and portal node software to the tempdir
        for s in (self.federation_software, self.portal_software):
            for l, f in s:
                base = os.path.basename(f)
                copy_file(f, "%s/%s" % (softdir, base))


    def initialize_experiment_info(self, attrs, aid, certfile, tmpdir):
        """
        Gather common configuration files, retrieve or create an experiment
        name and project name, and return the ssh_key filenames.  Create an
        allocation log bound to the state log variable as well. 
        """
        configs = ('hosts', 'ssh_pubkey', 'ssh_secretkey', 
                'seer_ca_pem', 'seer_node_pem', 'route.tgz')
        ename = None
        pubkey_base = None
        secretkey_base = None
        proj = None
        user = None
        alloc_log = None
        nonce_experiment = False
        vchars_re = '[^' + string.ascii_letters + string.digits  + '-]'

        self.state_lock.acquire()
        if aid in self.allocation:
            proj = self.allocation[aid].get('project', None)
        self.state_lock.release()

        if not proj:
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, 
                    "Can't find project for %s" %aid)

        for a in attrs:
            if a['attribute'] in configs:
                try:
                    self.log.debug("Retrieving %s from %s" % \
                            (a['attribute'], a['value']))
                    get_url(a['value'], certfile, tmpdir, log=self.log)
                except:
                    t, v, st = sys.exc_info()
                    raise service_error(service_error.internal,
                            "Error retrieving %s: %s" % (a.get('value', ""), v))
            if a['attribute'] == 'ssh_pubkey':
                pubkey_base = a['value'].rpartition('/')[2]
            if a['attribute'] == 'ssh_secretkey':
                secretkey_base = a['value'].rpartition('/')[2]
            if a['attribute'] == 'experiment_name':
                ename = a['value']

        # Names longer than the emulab max are discarded
        if ename and len(ename) <= self.max_name_len:
            # Clean up the experiment name so that emulab will accept it.
            ename = re.sub(vchars_re, '-', ename)

        else:
            ename = ""
            for i in range(0,5):
                ename += random.choice(string.ascii_letters)
            nonce_experiment = True
            self.log.warn("No experiment name or suggestion too long: " + \
                    "picked one randomly: %s" % ename)

        if not pubkey_base:
            raise service_error(service_error.req, 
                    "No public key attribute")

        if not secretkey_base:
            raise service_error(service_error.req, 
                    "No secret key attribute")

        self.state_lock.acquire()
        if aid in self.allocation:
            user = self.allocation[aid].get('user', None)
            cert = self.allocation[aid].get('cert', None)
            self.allocation[aid]['experiment'] = ename
            self.allocation[aid]['nonce'] = nonce_experiment
            self.allocation[aid]['log'] = [ ]
            # Create a logger that logs to the experiment's state object as
            # well as to the main log file.
            alloc_log = logging.getLogger('fedd.access.%s' % ename)
            h = logging.StreamHandler(
                    list_log.list_log(self.allocation[aid]['log']))
            # XXX: there should be a global one of these rather than
            # repeating the code.
            h.setFormatter(logging.Formatter(
                "%(asctime)s %(name)s %(message)s",
                        '%d %b %y %H:%M:%S'))
            alloc_log.addHandler(h)
            self.write_state()
        self.state_lock.release()

        if not user:
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, 
                    "Can't find creation user for %s" %aid)

        return (ename, proj, user, cert, pubkey_base, secretkey_base, alloc_log)

    def decorate_topology(self, info, t):
        """
        Copy the physical mapping and status onto the topology.  Used by
        StartSegment and InfoSegment
        """
        def add_new(ann, attr):
            for a in ann:
                if a not in attr: attr.append(a)

        def merge_os(os, e):
            if len(e.os) == 0:
                # No OS at all:
                if os.get_attribute('emulab_access:image'):
                    os.set_attribute('emulab_access:initial_image', 
                            os.get_attribute('emulab_access:image'))
                e.os = [ os ]
            elif len(e.os) == 1:
                # There's one OS, copy the initial image and replace
                eos = e.os[0]
                initial = eos.get_attribute('emulab_access:initial_image')
                if initial:
                    os.set_attribute('emulab_access:initial_image', initial)
                e.os = [ os] 
            else:
                # Multiple OSes, replace or append
                for eos in e.os:
                    if os.name == eos.name:
                        eos.version = os.version
                        eos.version = os.distribution
                        eos.version = os.distributionversion
                        for a in os.attribute:
                            if eos.get_attribute(a.attribute):
                                eos.remove_attribute(a.attribute)
                            eos.set_attribute(a.attribute, a.value)
                        break
                else:
                    e.os.append(os)


        if t is None: return
        i = 0 # For fake debugging instantiation
        # Copy the assigned names into the return topology
        for e in t.elements:
            if isinstance(e, topdl.Computer):
                if not self.create_debug:
                    if e.name in info.node:
                        add_new(("%s%s" % 
                            (info.node[e.name].pname, self.domain),),
                            e.localname)
                        add_new(("%s%s" % 
                            (info.node[e.name].lname, self.domain),),
                            e.localname)
                        e.status = info.node[e.name].status
                        os = info.node[e.name].getOS()
                        if os: merge_os(os, e)
                else:
                    # Simple debugging assignment
                    add_new(("node%d%s" % (i, self.domain),), e.localname)
                    e.status = 'active'
                    add_new(('testop1', 'testop2'), e.operation)
                    i += 1

        for s in t.substrates:
            if s.name in info.subs:
                sub = info.subs[s.name]
                if sub.cap is not None:
                    s.capacity = topdl.Capacity(sub.cap, 'max')
                if sub.delay is not None:
                    s.delay = topdl.Latency(sub.delay, 'max')
        # XXX interfaces


    def finalize_experiment(self, starter, topo, aid, alloc_id, proof):
        """
        Store key bits of experiment state in the global repository, including
        the response that may need to be replayed, and return the response.
        """
        def get_localnames(t):
            names = [ ]
            for e in t.elements:
                if isinstance(e, topdl.Computer):
                    n = e.get_attribute('testbed')
                    if n is not None and n not in names:
                        names.append(n)
            return names
        i = 0
        t = topo.clone()
        self.decorate_topology(starter, t)
        # Grab the log (this is some anal locking, but better safe than
        # sorry)
        self.state_lock.acquire()
        # Put information about this testbed into the topdl
        tb = topdl.Testbed(self.uri, "deter",
                localname=get_localnames(t), 
                attribute=[ 
                    { 
                        'attribute': 'project', 
                        'value': self.allocation[aid]['project']
                    },
                    { 
                        'attribute': 'experiment', 
                        'value': self.allocation[aid]['experiment']
                    }])
        t.elements.append(tb)
        logv = "".join(self.allocation[aid]['log'])
        # It's possible that the StartSegment call gets retried (!). 
        # if the 'started' key is in the allocation, we'll return it rather
        # than redo the setup.
        self.allocation[aid]['started'] = { 
                'allocID': alloc_id,
                'allocationLog': logv,
                'segmentdescription': { 
                    'topdldescription': t.to_dict()
                    },
                'proof': proof.to_dict(),
                }
        self.allocation[aid]['topo'] = t
        retval = copy.copy(self.allocation[aid]['started'])
        self.write_state()
        self.state_lock.release()
        return retval
    
    # End of StartSegment support routines

    def StartSegment(self, req, fid):
        err = None  # Any service_error generated after tmpdir is created
        rv = None   # Return value from segment creation

        self.log.info("StartSegment called by %s" % fid)
        try:
            req = req['StartSegmentRequestBody']
            auth_attr = req['allocID']['fedid']
            topref = req['segmentdescription']['topdldescription']
        except KeyError:
            raise service_error(server_error.req, "Badly formed request")

        connInfo = req.get('connection', [])
        services = req.get('service', [])
        aid = "%s" % auth_attr
        attrs = req.get('fedAttr', [])

        access_ok, proof = self.auth.check_attribute(fid, auth_attr, 
                with_proof=True)
        if not access_ok:
            self.log.info("StartSegment for %s failed: access denied" % fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.access, "Access denied")
        else:
            # See if this is a replay of an earlier succeeded StartSegment -
            # sometimes SSL kills 'em.  If so, replay the response rather than
            # redoing the allocation.
            self.state_lock.acquire()
            retval = self.allocation[aid].get('started', None)
            self.state_lock.release()
            if retval:
                self.log.warning("Duplicate StartSegment for %s: " % aid + \
                        "replaying response")
                return retval

        # A new request.  Do it.

        if topref: topo = topdl.Topology(**topref)
        else:
            raise service_error(service_error.req, 
                    "Request missing segmentdescription'")
        
        certfile = "%s/%s.pem" % (self.certdir, auth_attr)
        try:
            tmpdir = tempfile.mkdtemp(prefix="access-")
            softdir = "%s/software" % tmpdir
            os.mkdir(softdir)
        except EnvironmentError:
            self.log.info("StartSegment for %s failed: internal error" % fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, "Cannot create tmp dir")

        # Try block alllows us to clean up temporary files.
        try:
            self.retrieve_software(topo, certfile, softdir)
            ename, proj, user, xmlrpc_cert, pubkey_base, secretkey_base, \
                alloc_log =  self.initialize_experiment_info(attrs, aid, 
                        certfile, tmpdir)
            # A misconfigured cert in the ABAC map can be confusing...
            if not os.access(xmlrpc_cert, os.R_OK):
                self.log.error("Cannot open user's emulab SSL cert: %s" % \
                        xmlrpc_cert)
                raise service_error(service_error.internal,
                        "Cannot open user's emulab SSL cert: %s" % xmlrpc_cert)


            if '/' in proj: proj, gid = proj.split('/')
            else: gid = None


            # Set up userconf and seer if needed
            self.configure_userconf(services, tmpdir)
            self.configure_seer_services(services, topo, softdir)
            # Get and send synch store variables
            self.export_store_info(certfile, proj, ename, connInfo)
            self.import_store_info(certfile, connInfo)

            expfile = "%s/experiment.tcl" % tmpdir

            self.generate_portal_configs(topo, pubkey_base, 
                    secretkey_base, tmpdir, proj, ename, connInfo, services)
            self.generate_ns2(topo, expfile, 
                    "/proj/%s/software/%s/" % (proj, ename), connInfo)

            starter = self.start_segment(keyfile=self.ssh_privkey_file, 
                    debug=self.create_debug, log=alloc_log, boss=self.boss,
                    ops=self.ops, cert=xmlrpc_cert)
            rv = starter(self, ename, proj, user, expfile, tmpdir, gid=gid)
        except service_error, e:
            self.log.info("StartSegment for %s failed: %s"  % (fid, e))
            err = e
        except:
            t, v, st = sys.exc_info()
            self.log.info("StartSegment for %s failed:unexpected error: %s" \
                    % (fid, traceback.extract_tb(st)))
            err = service_error(service_error.internal, "%s: %s" % \
                    (v, traceback.extract_tb(st)))

        # Walk up tmpdir, deleting as we go
        if self.cleanup: self.remove_dirs(tmpdir)
        else: self.log.debug("[StartSegment]: not removing %s" % tmpdir)

        if rv:
            self.log.info("StartSegment for %s succeeded" % fid)
            return self.finalize_experiment(starter, topo, aid, req['allocID'],
                    proof)
        elif err:
            raise service_error(service_error.federant,
                    "Swapin failed: %s" % err)
        else:
            raise service_error(service_error.federant, "Swapin failed")

    def TerminateSegment(self, req, fid):
        self.log.info("TerminateSegment called by %s" % fid)
        try:
            req = req['TerminateSegmentRequestBody']
        except KeyError:
            raise service_error(server_error.req, "Badly formed request")

        auth_attr = req['allocID']['fedid']
        aid = "%s" % auth_attr
        attrs = req.get('fedAttr', [])

        access_ok, proof = self.auth.check_attribute(fid, auth_attr, 
                with_proof=True)
        if not access_ok:
            raise service_error(service_error.access, "Access denied")

        self.state_lock.acquire()
        if aid in self.allocation:
            proj = self.allocation[aid].get('project', None)
            user = self.allocation[aid].get('user', None)
            xmlrpc_cert = self.allocation[aid].get('cert', None)
            ename = self.allocation[aid].get('experiment', None)
            nonce = self.allocation[aid].get('nonce', False)
        else:
            proj = None
            user = None
            ename = None
            nonce = False
            xmlrpc_cert = None
        self.state_lock.release()

        if not proj:
            self.log.info("TerminateSegment failed for %s: cannot find project"\
                    % fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, 
                    "Can't find project for %s" % aid)
        else:
            if '/' in proj: proj, gid = proj.split('/')
            else: gid = None

        if not user:
            self.log.info("TerminateSegment failed for %s: cannot find user"\
                    % fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, 
                    "Can't find creation user for %s" % aid)
        if not ename:
            self.log.info(
                    "TerminateSegment failed for %s: cannot find experiment"\
                    % fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, 
                    "Can't find experiment name for %s" % aid)
        
        stopper = self.stop_segment(keyfile=self.ssh_privkey_file,
                debug=self.create_debug, boss=self.boss, ops=self.ops,
                cert=xmlrpc_cert)
        stopper(self, user, proj, ename, gid, nonce)
        self.log.info("TerminateSegment succeeded for %s %s %s" % \
                (fid, proj, ename))
        self.state_lock.acquire()
        # Remove the started flag/info - the segment is no longer started
        if aid in self.allocation:
            if 'started' in self.allocation[aid]:
                del self.allocation[aid]['started']
            self.write_state()
        self.state_lock.release()
        return { 'allocID': req['allocID'], 'proof': proof.to_dict() }

    def InfoSegment(self, req, fid):
        self.log.info("InfoSegment called by %s" % fid)
        try:
            req = req['InfoSegmentRequestBody']
        except KeyError:
            raise service_error(server_error.req, "Badly formed request")

        auth_attr = req['allocID']['fedid']
        aid = "%s" % auth_attr

        access_ok, proof = self.auth.check_attribute(fid, auth_attr, 
                with_proof=True)
        if not access_ok:
            raise service_error(service_error.access, "Access denied")

        self.state_lock.acquire()
        if aid in self.allocation:
            topo = self.allocation[aid].get('topo', None)
            if topo: topo = topo.clone()
            proj = self.allocation[aid].get('project', None)
            user = self.allocation[aid].get('user', None)
            xmlrpc_cert = self.allocation[aid].get('cert', None)
            ename = self.allocation[aid].get('experiment', None)
        else:
            proj = None
            user = None
            ename = None
            topo = None
            xmlrpc_cert = None
        self.state_lock.release()

        if not proj:
            self.log.info("InfoSegment failed for %s: cannot find project"% fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, 
                    "Can't find project for %s" % aid)
        else:
            if '/' in proj: proj, gid = proj.split('/')
            else: gid = None

        if not user:
            self.log.info("InfoSegment failed for %s: cannot find user"% fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, 
                    "Can't find creation user for %s" % aid)
        if not ename:
            self.log.info("InfoSegment failed for %s: cannot find exp"% fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.internal, 
                    "Can't find experiment name for %s" % aid)
        info = self.info_segment(keyfile=self.ssh_privkey_file,
                debug=self.create_debug, boss=self.boss, ops=self.ops,
                cert=xmlrpc_cert)
        info(self, user, proj, ename)
        self.log.info("InfoSegment gathered info for %s %s %s %s" % \
                (fid, user, proj, ename))
        self.decorate_topology(info, topo)
        self.state_lock.acquire()
        if aid in self.allocation:
            self.allocation[aid]['topo'] = topo
            self.write_state()
        self.state_lock.release()
        self.log.info("InfoSegment updated info for %s %s %s %s" % \
                (fid, user, proj, ename))

        rv = { 
                'allocID': req['allocID'], 
                'proof': proof.to_dict(),
                }
        self.log.info("InfoSegment succeeded info for %s %s %s %s" % \
                (fid, user, proj, ename))
        if topo:
            rv['segmentdescription'] = { 'topdldescription' : topo.to_dict() }
        return rv

    def OperationSegment(self, req, fid):
        def get_pname(e):
            """
            Get the physical name of a node
            """
            if e.localname:
                return re.sub('\..*','', e.localname[0])
            else:
                return None

        self.log.info("OperationSegment called by %s" % fid)
        try:
            req = req['OperationSegmentRequestBody']
        except KeyError:
            raise service_error(server_error.req, "Badly formed request")

        auth_attr = req['allocID']['fedid']
        aid = "%s" % auth_attr

        access_ok, proof = self.auth.check_attribute(fid, auth_attr, 
                with_proof=True)
        if not access_ok:
            self.log.info("OperationSegment failed for %s: access denied" % fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.access, "Access denied")

        op = req.get('operation', None)
        targets = req.get('target', None)
        params = req.get('parameter', None)

        if op is None :
            self.log.info("OperationSegment failed for %s: no operation" % fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.req, "missing operation")
        elif targets is None:
            self.log.info("OperationSegment failed for %s: no targets" % fid)
            raise service_error(service_error.req, "no targets")

        self.state_lock.acquire()
        if aid in self.allocation:
            topo = self.allocation[aid].get('topo', None)
            if topo: topo = topo.clone()
            xmlrpc_cert = self.allocation[aid].get('cert', None)
        else:
            topo = None
            xmlrpc_cert = None
        self.state_lock.release()

        targets = copy.copy(targets)
        ptargets = { }
        for e in topo.elements:
            if isinstance(e, topdl.Computer):
                if e.name in targets:
                    targets.remove(e.name)
                    pn = get_pname(e)
                    if pn: ptargets[e.name] = pn

        status = [ operation_status(t, operation_status.no_target) \
                for t in targets]

        ops = self.operation_segment(keyfile=self.ssh_privkey_file,
                debug=self.create_debug, boss=self.boss, ops=self.ops,
                cert=xmlrpc_cert)
        ops(self, op, ptargets, params, topo)
        self.log.info("OperationSegment operated for %s" % fid)
        
        status.extend(ops.status)
        self.log.info("OperationSegment succeed for %s" % fid)

        return { 
                'allocID': req['allocID'], 
                'status': [s.to_dict() for s in status],
                'proof': proof.to_dict(),
                }